It is a close call between SPJIMR and JBIMS. NMIMS is not in the same league as these but it is a decent B-School and ranked among the top 30 in India. JBIMS has the highest rank. Indiatoday 2021 ranked the institute 12 for MBA.
JBIMS offers better ROI. Course fees for the institute are INR 6.05 Lakhs. While the average CTC for the institute is INR 27 LPA, according to JBIMS placements highlights of 2022. If you are interested in Finance, you should choose JBIMS.
If you are interested in Marketing and Ops, you should go for SP Jain.
Chances are that you have completed the MSc Finance program of JBIMS and yet are not very satisfied with the results and sure about your career prospects. I suggest you 2 ways to get out of this situation
The other option is not to do an MBA and stay where you are. You might not be ready to spend 2 years again studying considering the opportunity cost of not working for two years. In case you see no major diff between the two programs, you can just give up pursuing MBA altogether.
Any gap during your career needs to be justified adequately. The gap won’t affect your chances of getting a call as that is solely based on CET score, academic performance, extracurricular activities, and work experience. It is your personal interview that might face problems due to your gap.
The interviewer might assert that you can’t multitask or you don’t understand the importance of time as many students prepare while working. You need to note that the interviewer is not here to demotivate you or insult you. You need to give them a valid reason for your gap and if provided one, they might overlook it at once. The fact that you got a call and got shortlisted is enough justification for the gap.
Apart from your MBA preparation, they will inquire about the additional skills you acquired during that period. These may include any extracurricular activity, an internship, any specific skill or a new language you have learned, any freelancing or any course you got enrolled in. You can also be acquired about what you gained or learned from your gap period.
I don’t personally think a gap can limit your chances provided you offer a very convincing reason in the interview.
Both the colleges are reputed among students and offer decent ROI, a well-connected alumni network, and good placement opportunities.
Let’s have an overview for both the colleges one by one.
JBIMS:
VGSoM:
JBIMS Mumbai offers MIMS while VGSoM offers MBA. Both the institutes are good.
Candidates must keep in mind that to admit candidates in MMS courses, Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of Management Studies, Mumbai uses MAH CET, CAT, and CMAT scores. For all category candidates, those who secure ranks or marks as per the cutoff of JBIMS Mumbai are called for the common admission process (CAP).
The minimum scores one needs to get into JBIMS are mentioned below:
|
Category |
MAH CET Score |
CAT Score |
CMAT score |
|
General |
95 or < |
93 or < |
95 or < |
|
SC/ST/OBC |
90 or < |
75 or < |
75 or < |
|
PwD |
87 or < |
70 or < |
75 or < |
FMS Delhi, XLRI, XIMB, and JBIMS are all highly regarded B-schools in India that offer postgraduate management programs. As these programs are PG courses so they require candidates to have a bachelor's degree from a recognized university.
The number of seats and admission criteria for these programs may vary from year to year and depend on factors such as the number of applicants, the performance of the applicants in entrance exams, and the selection process of each institution. Below is a table of batch sizes of all these colleges;
|
Institution |
Program |
Approximate Batch Size |
|
FMS Delhi |
MBA |
200 |
|
XLRI |
PGDM |
360 |
|
XIMB |
MBA |
360 |
|
JBIMS Mumbai |
MMS |
120 |
Although all these institutes try to keep the batch as diverse as possible still the ratio of B.Tech and non-B.Tech is highly skewed towards B.Tech. So, it is unlikely that less than 60 B.Tech graduates are admitted to these institutions. These institutions typically have a rigorous selection process, and the number of seats available is usually limited.
However, the exact number of B.Tech graduates admitted to these institutions may vary depending on the specific program and admission cycle.
JBIMS is located in Mumbai, India, and offers admission to its Master of Management Studies (MMS) program through the Maharashtra Common Entrance Test (CET) for domiciles of Maharashtra.
The number of seats available at JBIMS through the CET for domiciles may vary from year to year depending on the decisions of the regulatory authorities.
In general, JBIMS offers around 156 seats where 120 seats are offered under the Maharastra state category, 18 seats are offered in the All-India Category, and the rest of the seats are offered in NRI and foreign nationals categories. Admission in the All-India category is given on the basis of CAT and CMAT Score also need to appear for the MAH-CET and participate in the CAP process, conducted by DTE Maharashtra for its MMS program through the CET for domiciles.
The selection process for a company is typically comprised of several steps. First, you will express your interest in the company through a google form or similar mechanism. The company will then release its initial shortlists. The next step is a group or case discussion of the shortlisted students. Finally, the interview process will take place, which may consist of one or two rounds, for those who clear the group/case discussion round(s).
The shortlisting process is based on the batch profile that is shared with recruiters. Companies usually have a shortlisting criterion, such as a minimum percentage in academics or a certain amount of work experience, which they use to create their shortlist. It is important to note that academic projects are typically completed in the first 1-2 months of joining a company, and these projects are added to the CVs of all students. However, HRs do not have enough time to go through individual profiles while creating the initial shortlist, so they rely on evidence such as academics and work experience.
You will experience significant improvements in the facilities at JBIMS compared to before. The difference between the old and new classrooms can be seen with the newly built rooms, which were sponsored by alumni. However, being a part of the University of Mumbai, making major changes to the infrastructure took a lot of time and required permission from various departments.
Campus life at JBIMS has been filled with challenges and tests of your ability. It is not like regular college life and the rigor of B-school life at JBIMS is on par with what you would expect at the IIMs.
Choosing a B-school can be a tricky decision especially when it comes to ROI. I understand that ROI is one of the most important factors when it comes to MBA courses since funding your education with loans come with its own set of challenges. But the institutes that you have mentioned above certainly surpass the challenges since they belong to the tier 1 category.
You might come across articles and blogs stating that FMS or JBIMS do not provide a typical MBA environment but for me, that discussion does not even make sense. What is an MBA environment after all? You spent 2 years of your life at the campus and wish to land a good job. FMS, JBIMS, and IIT Bombay all three have good market reputations, they home the best candidates and charge minimal fees. So, if ROI is even a little bit of a concern for you, go for these colleges without any second thought or regret.