KEM Mumbai, Mumbai Comparison

The sole reason many medical aspirants choose Seth GS for MBBS over GMC Mumbai is the quality of education it offers which places it somewhat higher than GMC. 

Grant Medical College is indeed a well-known medical college but not yet at par with KEM at least in terms of academics. KEM welcomes the best student crowd and churns out many great doctors. 

Seth GS on the other hand is at the same level as the top medical colleges of India, AIIMS and JIPMER in terms of academics. However, it’s yet to match its level of infrastructure, clinical exposure, and research opportunities.

Grant is known to have very old infrastructure, with issues related to internal politics and corruption. However, most ranking magazines place GMC over Seth GS thereby misleading many.

So always consider all the aspects before choosing your college. 

GMC Mumbai and GSMC have always been compared to each other. 

GSMC has great academics and a very competitive environment. GMC is much more relaxed. At GMC, you’ll come across a variety of students- from nerds to all-rounders, to those who study the night before an exam. 

Toppers generally choose GSMC as their first preference. But those who spend some time in Grant, usually refuse to be upgraded to GSMC. Grant students are better at extracurriculars, while GSMC students are on average, more studious.

Both are good for an MBBS degree. You should choose between them based on your personal preference.

Based on the opinions within the medical community, I will provide some information on these colleges-

1. GSMC- It is a highly renowned college. High rankers in UG and PG entrance choose it for pursuing their medical studies. Clinical teaching is very good over here. 
2. Grant Medical College Mumbai- It is one of the top 10 medical colleges of India. But its fees have skyrocketed recently. The campus is not in a good shape too. However, this college is one of the only 5 colleges whose degrees are approved in Singapore. So if you plan to pursue your PG abroad, a degree from GMC Mumbai will open the doors of Singapore for you.
3. KGMU- It is one of the best medical colleges in North India, and especially UP. It is well reputed, and the campus is really good. The infrastructure is top notch, better than most government colleges. The teachers are decent, and the students are hardworking. You’ll get a good clinical exposure over here. For an outsider though, adjusting to the UP culture might be a little difficult at first.

I don’t know much about GMC Patiala and GMCH Chandigarh, so I won’t comment on these two. 

Make sure to choose a college with hardworking students. Good company will motivate you to study harder and excel in your field. Food and language barriers aren’t much of a problem in the long run. 

Trust me there is no right answer to your question as the choice of the institute is a matter of personal inclinations and goals. However here are a few points you would like to consider before selecting your college

• Academically, the quality of education and the research facilities available are similar in all the aforementioned institutes and so you choosing one over the other will not compromise your education.
• The primary factor should be location. Here there are 2 things to consider proximity to your home and the kind of college life you want. If you want a tranquil and calm life go for AIMS Rishikesh but if you are a city lover, go for Seth GS.
• Infrastructure-wise, AIIMS definitely gives an edge to Seth GS. The modern campus, with top-notch equipment and hostel facilities, offers a more comfortable and modern college life than an old institute like Seth GS. 
• Being a central institute, AIIMS offers more exposure to diverse cultures and a mixed student body.
• AIIMS Rishikesh follows a total MCQ exam pattern making it easier for NEET PG preparation. 
• The most lucrative aspect of AIIMS is the tag associated with it. You will forever be honored for being a part of an institute of national importance.
• There is no bond policy in AIIMSwhereas Seth GS has one.

Now it depends on you to decide which factor attracts you and which factor you are ready to overlook. Once you have weighed all points only then you can arrive at a wise decision.

My answer is a bit biased towards GSMC as my brother is an alumnus of the same. However, I’ll try my best to justify my bias towards it.

• AIIMS Nagpur is a newly established college whereas Seth GSMC was established in 1926. It enjoys a better reputation than AIIMS Nagpur currently.
• As for the bond, GSMC is under the umbrella of MCGM, so you will be spared from serving the bond in a rural area and will have to serve in BMC Hospital.
• Because of its reputation, GSMC has a better reputation than AIIMS Nagpur and people from all over the country come here. 
• GSMC has some of the most friendly seniors you could ask for. They help you in every possible way and there is no ragging at all.
• As for USMLE, it requires guidance from seniors who have established themselves there. This is possible in GSMC because of a wider alumni base.
• GSMC has the latest amenities with well-established departments providing the best research opportunities. 
• The MLT and LTs are now fully air-conditioned. 

Ultimately, it’s best to look at the bigger picture and not focus only on the AIIMS tag. GSMC is better in terms of academics as well as reputation. No doubt, lack of hostel facilities does matter but not for someone who is ready to commit himself to the field. 

The best way to determine which is better between AIIMS Nagpur and KEM Mumbai is to analyze the pros and cons of these institutes individually and then come to a decision.

AIIMS Nagpur Pros

• AIIMS Nagpur fees are very low around INR 5,856 fit the entire course (Mess not included)
• AIIMS Nagpur has all the nicer menu ties and infrastructure. Some of these include a Gym, 2 indoor badminton courts, a basketball court, a volleyball court, cricket and football ground.
• Hostel facilities are also decent with single rooms for girls and shared rooms for boys in the first year only. Every floor has a washing machine and the hostel is Wi-fi enabled
• Excellent connectivity with the nearest metro station 3 km away
• The academic environment is state of the art with labs equipped with modern instruments.

AIIMS Nagpur Cons

• Being a new AIIMS, it does not have a very huge orient inflow with limited clinical exposure 
• Being located on the outskirts of the city, you can go out only during weekends
• There is no student association and CR selection is done on the basis of marks.
• There aren’t many shops so you will have to depend on online shopping. 

KEM Pros

• KEM is a highly regarded medical college
• The PG of KEM is considered of high value in India
• The college offers a vibrant city life thanks to its Mumbai location
• There isn’t any ragging and the Bodh between seniors and juniors is strong
• Being old, the institute has an extensive alumni base 
• The patient flow is huge because of the reputation and location of the college.

KEM Cons

• Obviously, being in Mumbai you will have to bear a very high cost of living.
• The fees are very high. KEM Mumbai M.B.B.S. fees are INR 5.54 L
• There are no hostel facilities for first-year students.
• 1-year bond with heavy internship
• Not a good option for USMLE aspirants as there is a rule that prohibits you from leaving India for 5 years.

After weighing the above pros and cons I conclude that AIIMS Nagpur is a better option as its pros definitely overwrite the cons.

It is widely held that the Mumbai work structure is extremely beneficial and makes you more confident and open.

GSMC has a bond, so you must work for a year after graduation, whereas AIIMS does not have a bond. As one of the most prominent leading institutes in Maharashtra, GSMC has excellent technical infrastructure. It has a higher patient flow, which is very important. It also has more advanced clinical departments. The faculty is an incredible and enthusiastic supporter. It is affiliated with other BMC colleges, giving you more opportunities, and it is also affiliated with prestigious institutions such as Tata Memorial and Wadia Hospital.

AIIMS Raipur is a good choice because of the AIIMS brand, infrastructure, and smaller batch size, but GSMC is still suggested.