Get Answers on Test Preparation, Admissions & Campus Life
Study Abroad Countries
For marketing, which among SIBM-Pune, NMIMS-Mumbai or MICA is the best?
If you're looking to specialize in marketing and work in fields such as strategic communication, advertising, and media management, then MICA would be the perfect fit for you. They offer a range of courses and programs that focus specifically on marketing, making it an ideal choice for those who want to go deep in this field.
However, if you're an engineer looking for a more general approach to sales and marketing, you may want to consider NMIMS Mumbai, SIBM Pune, or IMT Ghaziabad. All three institutes are similar in their approach to marketing, but each has its unique advantages and disadvantages.
NMIMS Mumbai, for example, has a higher cost and a smaller campus compared to SIBM and IMT. However, it also boasts a strong brand and alumni network, which can be very advantageous when it comes to finding jobs or internships. Additionally, the packages offered by NMIMS are generally higher than those at IMT and slightly better than SIBM.
On the other hand, SIBM Pune and IMT Ghaziabad offer a larger campus and a more affordable cost of attendance. However, they may not have the same level of brand recognition or alumni network as NMIMS Mumbai.
Ultimately, it comes down to what you value most in an institute. If you want a strong brand and alumni network and are willing to pay a higher cost for it, then NMIMS Mumbai might be the right choice for you. If you're looking for a more affordable option with a larger campus, then SIBM Pune or IMT Ghaziabad may be a better fit.
How are the placements at other B-schools like S.P Jain, JBIMS, NMIMS, SIBM and XLRI compared to the IIMs? Is it worth joining these institutes?
Although all the institutes offer good placement to its students, a comparative analytical report based on points would be helpful for you to decide which institute to choose for your higher studies.
XLRI:
-
Some of the top recruiters who offer internship and job opportunities to the XLRI students are Aditya Birla Group, Amazon, Microsoft, are ITC, JP Morgan, Ramco Systems, Accenture, Sapient, ATG Tires, Lodha Group, RPG, Udaan, P&G, Colgate Palmolive, Ola, Myntra, Samsung, C K Birla, Power Finance Corporation among others.
-
The highest and medium salary packages remain to be around 50 LPA and 12-15 LPA.
IIML:
-
It offers 100% placement to its students.
-
The top recruiters are JCB India, Bosch, Apparel group, Tolaram Group, RPG Group, and more.
-
The highest and the medium salary range remain to be around 54 LPA and 23 LPA.
IIMK:
-
Students at IIMK get 98% placement and the highest and the medium salary package remains to be around 40 LPA and 18 LPA.
-
Some of the top recruiters who offer internship and job opportunities are Cognizant, Wipro, Amazon, Airtel, City Bank, Deloitte, Nestle, Bosch, Microsoft, Raymond, and more.
SIBM Pune:
It was ranked 6th by Outlook India in 2020.
-
The top recruiters who offer placement to the students are Axis Bank, Flipkart, Diageo, KPMG, Capgemini, HDFC Bank, Mahindra CIE, ITC, and more.
-
The highest and the medium packages are 34 LPA and 18 LPA.
NMIMS:
NMIMS has ranked 2nd among the top BBA colleges of India by India Today in 2020.
-
Top recruiters of NMIMS students are IBM, Johnson, and Johnson, Deloitte, ICICI, HDFC Bank, Cadila, Mankind, Accenture, Amdocs, Bajaj Finserv, Aditya Birla Group, Alkem, Cipla, and more.
-
The highest and medium salary packages remain to be around 30 LPA and 17 LPA.
JBIMS:
-
Students receive job opportunities from various companies such as Mahindra Group, TATA Group, The Boston Consulting Group, Reliance Industries, Godrej consumer products, and more.
-
The highest and medium packages that are offered are 32 LPA and 26 LPA.
These are the major placement related details that you should be taking into account while deciding whether you want to join any of these institutes or not.
Which college should be preferred? SIBM Pune or IIM Shillong?
Most MBA aspirants prefer IIM Shillong over SIBM Pune. Having an IIM degree certainly offers some perks. You will get better placement opportunities and exposure. IIM Shillong placements 2022 had an average CTC of around INR 21.71 LPA. The highest CTC offered this year was INR 32.2 LPA. The institute offers a high ROI.
What do I prepare for SIBM, SCMHRD interviews?
You can never guess what the interviewer will ask in the interview, no matter how well-read you’re and how comfortable you are with talking about the current happenings. Still, it always helps boost your confidence and gives you a chance to take the conversation in any direction you want.
- Start with the basics and read your resume 10 times a day before your interview; prepare 3-4 lines on every keyword mentioned in your resume.
- Be aware of the news that aligns with your interest in any manner according to your resume. For example, if you have work experience and left the company last year, just check if it’s on the news or has undergone any major changes after your exit.
- Always have a few good achievements examples ready to back your stories up.
Remember, you don’t need to know everything you’re asked, it certainly helps if you know everything but trust me the panel is observing your approach towards a particular question. So all the best!!
How was your interview experience at IIM, FMS, MDI, XLRI, SP JAIN, NMIMS, SIBM, SCMHRD, etc. being from a commerce background ?
I can tell you about my interview experience for IIM Kozhikode.
I am a working professional with three years of work experience in the Ed-tech field. My 10th is 9.4 CGPA, 12th is 80% , both from CBSE, graduation score is 71.2% and I graduated in BBA in 2018 from a college in Indore .
I gave my interview in the afternoon slot (there were a total of three slots, morning, afternoon, and evening, the morning slot is best).
The interview was in online mode (due to covid). First, they asked me to verify my official ID cards. There were two people taking my interview, one male and one female.
They started by asking about my hobbies, I told them about gyming and cricket, and the male interviewer started asking me about cricket. He asked me who scored the maximum t20 runs in the previous year, what reverse swing is, top five bowlers who could bowl reverse swing. Then they started asking me about the firm in which I worked, the valuation of the firm, its reputation, the work culture, the future of the industry, who the CEO is, and all.
Then the next person started asking me questions from my undergrad, and I wasn't able to answer the question related to that. She seems a little unsatisfied with my answers.
I was waitlisted at the end and could not be able to convert the college.
Which college is good for MBA, Nirma University, Symbiosis Pune or Narsee Monjee Mumbai?
NMIMS is the best option among these. The strategic location, excellent placement, and brand value put NMIMS ahead of the other institute mentioned in the question.
NMIMS is located at the financial hub of Mumbai. The campus is just an hour or an hour and a half drive away from commercial and industrial spaces like Bandra Kurla Complex, Navi Mumbai, South Bombay, etc. Due to the locational advantage students can easily attend industrial visits of reputed organizations like TOI, Pepsico, JPMC, etc.
NMIMS Mumbai placements are way ahead of the B-Schools in the same tier. Even with a batch size of 500+, the institute offers an average CTC of INR 23.07 LPA.
What are the chances that I convert my calls from SIBM Pune, SCMHRD or SIBM Bangalore? How is the GE PIWAT given when I have a 98.0456 percentile?
It is difficult to predict your chances of converting your calls from SIBM Pune, SCMHRD, or SIBM Bangalore as apart from a good percentile in SNAP there are various factors that are taken into consideration during the selection process apart from the percentile in entrance exams. These factors include academic background, work experience (if any), performance in Group Exercise (GE), Personal Interview (PI), and Written Ability Test (WAT), among others.
|
Particulars |
SCMHRD Pune |
SIBM Pune |
SIBM Bangalore |
|
SNAP Score |
50% |
50% |
50% |
|
Group Exercise (GE) |
10% |
10% |
10% |
|
Personal Interview (PI) |
30% |
30% |
30% |
|
Writing Ability Test (WAT) |
10% |
10% |
10% |
|
Total |
100% |
100% |
100% |
Having a 98.0456 percentile is a good score and puts you in a competitive position for the admission process but that does not guarantee the final call as WAT weighted is important and big enough to ignore.
So, to increase your chances of converting your calls, you should prepare well for the GE, PI, and WAT rounds by improving your communication and presentation skills, staying updated with current affairs, practicing writing essays, and answering interview questions.
Which college would be better to pursue MBA from - NMIMS Mumbai or SIBM Pune?
A decent alternative for doing an MBA is NMIMS. Due to the fact that it provides specialism in areas like HR, business analytics, digital transformation, etc. In 1981, the famous organization NMIMS was established in Mumbai, Maharashtra. NMIMS is a deemed-to-be university with eight campuses located throughout India in Mumbai, Shirpur, Indore, Navi Mumbai, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Dhule, and Chandigarh. Here are a few factors that make NMIMS a suitable choice for those interested in pursuing this degree program:
- Ranking: NMIMS ranked #21 among the top MBA schools in India. Due to its high academic standards, emphasis on research, and professors drawn from the best national and international universities and businesses, NMIMS is considered to be at the forefront of great education.
- Accreditation: NMIMS Deemed-to University is accredited by NAAC with a 3.59 CGPA and Grade A+, whereas SIBM Pune is accredited by NAAC with an "A" grade
- Financial support: Students at NMIMS Mumbai are eligible for the Central Sector Scheme of Scholarships for economically disadvantaged General, SC, ST, and physically challenged groups.
- Placement: The majority of students who apply for placements in NMIMS are accepted. The comparison between the placement stats of these colleges are as follows:
|
Particulars |
NMIMS |
SIBM Pune |
|
Highest salary |
INR 67.80 LPA |
INR 35.05 LPA |
|
Average salary |
INR 26.63 LPA |
INR 26.77 LPA |
|
Top recruiters |
Aditya Birla Capital, American Express, Goldman Sachs, Crisil, etc. |
Accenture Strategy, Aditya Birla Capital, American Express, Barclays, HSBC, etc |
- Alumni network: Ashis Gupta (Managing Director and Head of Research, Credit Suisse India), Kamlesh Rao (Managing Director, Kotak Securities Ltd.) and many more established professionals are the notable alumni of this organization.
In conclusion, NMIMS is undeniably a commendable institution that continues to excel in its pursuit of academic excellence and professional as well as personal development. So based on these basic aspects NMIMS would be a better option for pursuing this course.
Is it worth doing an MBA from SIBM Pune, SCMHRD Pune or NMIMS Mumbai after 2 years of job experience in IT?
Yes, it’s worth it. In some cases, it is even essential to do an MBA after having 2 years of work experience in IT.
- There are different kinds of people in IT sectors, some who like the technicalities of IT and some don't like that. People who like the technicalities of IT will settle in just a couple of years by learning to code brilliantly and achieve their goals.
- Other people are just the opposite; they are always left feeling that they are missing something. MBA adds value to your resume and helps you to change your career.
I know a few people from SIBM Pane, so I can tell you about the MBA program offered by them.
- My friends at the institute have peers who come with work experience in the IT sector and are going to be working in big FMCG brands in the summers.
- SIBM Pune had an average CTC of around 20.14 LPA. The average internship stipend offered in the summer internship for 2018-20 was around 1.66 lacs for just two months and above 55% of students got offers for 1.5 lacs around. The highest stipend offered was 3 lacs.
Also, MBA can be a much-needed break for many with corporate careers. It’s a fun experience, you will get to learn a lot through many corporate interactions.
How is life after MBA from SIBM Pune and SCMHRD?
Top recruiters visit the campus and offer an average of 24-26 lakhs. The highest can go up to your capability. Whereas SCMHRD offers an average salary of 23-24 lakhs. These two colleges share a nearly identical average package and are classified as MBA schools (next to IIMs) in the same region. There isn't much of a difference when a company comes to campus because you frequently have to go through both campus interviews.
Top recruiters like Accenture, Adani, Aditya Birla Group, Bajaj Finserv, Cipla, etc. visit the campus to offer placement to the students of SIBM Pune. On the other hand companies like Google, ITC Limited, Flipkart, Deloitte, etc. visit SCMHRD for campus placement.
The table shows a brief overview of both institutions:
|
Particulars |
SIBM Placement 2023 |
SCMHRD Placement 2023 |
|---|---|---|
|
No. of Companies participated |
105 |
112+ |
|
No. of New Recruiters |
49 |
38 |
|
Highest Salary |
INR 35.05 LPA |
INR 67.60 LPA |
|
Average Salary |
INR 26.77 LPA |
INR 23.71 LPA |
|
Median Salary |
INR 24 LPA |
INR 22 LPA |
Considering these facts it is safe to conclude that life after completing an MBA at institutions like SIBM Pune or SCMHRD can lead to dynamic and rewarding careers, offering various opportunities for professional growth and personal development.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWS LETTER
