I have given the preference order of the above-mentioned B Schools. However please remember this is based on my personal opinions and not any official figures
1st: NMIMS is one of the best schools in Mumbai with fewer fees and great specialization in Finance. Its distinguishing feature is its small batch size which is extremely beneficial for excellent placements. The companies that visit offer the best roles to their students mainly because of their credibility and strong alumni network.
2nd: SPJIMR too is located in Mumbai and is the second-best School after JBMINS. Its students intake is very good due to the strict selection process. The placements are at par with JBIMS but the fees are a bit higher. It's ranked in the top 3 in Operation and IT specialization in India.
3rd: One of the oldest institutes for MBA, IIFT is a good choice owing to its strong brand name and small batch size.
4th: SIBM Pune is a blend of everything; a Good campus, good corporate competition, hostel life, good infrastructure, faculty, and placement. It gives you an amazing MBA experience l.
5th: NMIMS Mumbai is great for MBA and is at par with SIBM. But I have ranked it the last owing to its high fees and larger batch size that requires a lot of competition during placements.
So the ranking is
NMIMS>SPJIMR>IIFT>SIBM Pune>NMIMS Mumbai
Among these two ISB is better. It has a better pool of faculties, better facilities, and a better alumni base. The placement opportunities offered at ISB are also better.
Here is a brief highlight of ISB Hyderabad placements 2022.
| Average CTC | INR 27.13 LPA |
| Median CTC | INR 27 LPA |
| Highest CTC | INR 72 LPA |
| Major recruiters | Mc Kinsey, Honeywell, Boston Consulting Group |
Access to the strong alumni base of ISB, is another perk of joining the institute.
It depends on which NMIMS you’re talking about. If you’re talking about NMIMS Mumbai. Then I would choose NMIMS.
Location: Between NMIMS & SCMHRD, Mumbai is one the best location to do an MBA as a large and good pool of companies will come to the campus.
Brand name- NMIMS has a better reputation and brand value then compared to SCMHRD. NMIMS stands proud as a Deemed-to-be University offering multiple disciplines across multiple campuses. What started as an institute in a small building has caught the attention of the world, thanks to its 17 specialized schools
Placements - NMIMS Mumbai average package offered to MBA Core and MBA HR students stood at INR 23.07 LPA and INR 19.40 LPA, respectively.
For a B.Tech NMIMS is better than Symbiosis Pune. It offers better placements and exposure. NMIMS placements are pretty good for B.Tech. Students receive an average CTC of around INR 6-7 LPA. NMIMS also offers better exposure to students. Due to the locational advantage, it’s easier for students to get good internships and placement opportunities.
Both colleges offer the best education in economics. Education World Organization has ranked Ashoka University in the 2nd place in the year 2019-2020. While the NMIMS is ranked in the 7th position by Business Today. Also, NMIMS is one of the top 100 lists of B-schools.
However, one should not decide the best college based on rankings and branding. So, here are a few facts about the economics course at both colleges.
NMIMS
Admissions:
Placements:
Additional Information:
Ashoka University
Admissions:
Placements:
Additional Information:
This is all about economics at both colleges. Choose the best college that suits you based on the various aspects and your interests.
Someone I know who is an alumnus of SCMHRD has said that finding out which college is better will bear little to no fruits.
You can get in touch with the professionals from both programs and try to understand what you will have to do in order to make a name for yourself. An internal analysis is involved after which it is gauged what field would be the most suitable for you.
NMIMS is popular for producing marketing professionals. Finance is also popular in the institute. Analytics is not the flagship course of SCMHRD. They are very different courses and your temperament and aptitude are also contributing factors.
NMIMS Mumbai and GIM are both reputed business schools in India. NMIMS Mumbai is ranked 25th and GIM is ranked 36th in the NIRF 2022 Rankings in Management.
PGDM Batch of 2023 at GIM has achieved a 100% placement, with the highest CTC at 55 LPA and an average CTC at 14.9 LPA. GIM offers a 2-year full-time PGDM. Classes are held on campus.
GIM also has a distance learning program by the name of GOAL-GIM Online Active Learning, which offers PGDM courses in the hybrid learning mode.
For NMIMS 2022-2023 MBA (Core) placements, the highest CTC (International) was 67.80 LPA and the average CTC was 26.63 LPA.
For MBA (HR) placements, the highest CTC was 25.95 LPA and the average CTC was 19.56 LPA.
NMIMS Mumbai offers a Distance PGDM, the duration of which is again 2 years.
NMIMS Mumbai is a more popular choice as compared to GIM, however, it also differs from one individual to the other.
Both NMIMS and St. Xavier’s are highly reputed institutes in Mumbai and ranked amongst the top 10. NMIMS is ranked 22nd by NIRF in the MBA category while St.Xavier’s is ranked 4th by The Week for Arts. NMIMS has international collaborations with University of Florida, TelAviv University and King's College London amongst many others. Both these institutes have highly qualified faculty who strive to curate global leaders.
Admission Process
NMIMS
St. Xavier’s
At St.Xavier’s, students are given admission for BMS based on a 60% weightage to Entrance Test and 40% weightage of Class XII aggregate marks.
Fee Structure
Placements
NMIMS
After BSc Economics at NMIMS, a student can pursue PG in economics/management, a career in finance/industry/banks, market research institutions as market analysts. The key placement highlights are:
St. Xavier’s
After BMS, a student can get into administration & operations, project management (executive level), enterprise management, human resource management & development, data management & system analysis, sales & marketing, and financial management. The notable features about placement statistics are:
BMS and BSc Economics are entirely different fields to compare. Selecting a course and a college depends much on the present industry developments apart from personal interest. It is upto the individual to analyse and come to a conclusion after considering the stats.
For EGMP certification from IIM Bangalore, you must have at least 5 years of experience, and the entire course fee is 6,76,000. The course is designed for working professionals who have not been exposed to many pivotal corporate shifts and want to broaden their managerial skills. The same would apply to an Executive MBA from NMIMS that requires a minimum of 3 years of work experience. Although there is a significant difference between the fees, it should not affect your choice if you’re planning on pursuing executive education. The brand image may not influence the chances of your success in the industry after working for more than 5 years. Still, it could definitely provide you with the right kind of assistance. So, in my opinion, you should go for IIM certification.
This program is not AICTE approved, which means you won't be able to give government exams. However, you can still get private jobs, but keep in mind that not many companies recognize this program, so there may be fewer job opportunities if you don't take up placement from the institute.
If you're planning to take admission in NMIMS, you should know that the admission fee is around Rs. 2,75,000. Paying around 25 lacs for a 5-year MBATech program may not be worth it. If you do decide to get a refund, you may face some problems. The person on the telephone might speak rudely, and the refund process can be time-consuming. Additionally, you need to send a cancellation form by post, which can also take some time.
There are cases where students have experienced some issues when they applied for a refund 20 days before the start of college, and they didn't receive a 100% refund. The college deducted 50000-55000 and provided reasons as to why the students weren't eligible for a full refund. Therefore, it's essential to do proper research, take suggestions from people, and read all the rules and regulations of UGC and AICTE before taking admission.
In summary, before taking admission to any institute, you should always do thorough research, take suggestions from others, and read all the rules and regulations. This will help you make an informed decision and avoid facing any problems later on.