I believe that the roles available in the finance sector at NMIMS are readily equivalent to those at IIFT, if not superior. Mumbai's location is quite advantageous for the institute. During placements, a sizable number of finance companies visited the campus.
However, there is fierce rivalry for these positions within the class, particularly among those who studied business as a major in undergrad. This is why it can be difficult for engineers pursuing an MBA at NM to be shortlisted for financial positions because financial institutions prefer to interview candidates with backgrounds in commerce. However, getting on a shortlist for financial roles becomes simpler if you are able to pass one or two levels of CFA or FRM.
In terms of financial roles, NMIMS = IIFT > new IIMs
When it comes to financing roles, NMIMS is generally seen as being on par with or even better than IIFT. One advantage of NMIMS is its location in Mumbai, which can be beneficial for students seeking finance roles. A decent number of finance companies visit the campus during placements, offering a good range of opportunities for students. However, it's worth noting that the competition for these roles can be quite intense, especially for students with engineering backgrounds. This is because finance companies often have a tendency to shortlist more students with commerce backgrounds for interviews.
That being said, if you are able to clear one or two levels of the CFA or FRM exams, it can become easier to get shortlisted for finance roles at NMIMS. Overall, when it comes to financing roles, NMIMS is generally seen as being on par with IIFT and better than the new IIMs.
Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of Management Studies or JBIMS is situated in Mumbai, Maharashtra, and Xavier Labour Relations Institute or XLRI is located at Jamshedpur, Jharkhand. For the year 2020, XLRI was ranked 9th by NIRF in the Management category. JBIMS has been ranked 7th by Business today.
Admission
JBIMS:
XLRI
Placements:
JBIMS
XLRI:
The table given below highlights the overall placement statistics for both institutions:
|
Aspect |
JBIMS |
XLRI |
|
Major recruiters |
Accenture Strategy, HDFC, Infosys Consulting, ICICI, Mahindra, Airtel, JP Morgan Chase & Co. |
KPMG, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Accenture, Microsoft, Amazon, P&G, GAIL. |
|
Highest CTC |
INR 32.3 LPA |
INR 58.22 LPA |
|
Average CTC |
INR 20.13 LPA |
INR 15.42 LPA |
Campus Life -
A better option for finance should be selected by comparing above facts, your perception of the college brand image and the ROI which is on an average 20.14 for JBIMS and 0.65:1 for XLRI.
IMI Delhi should definitely be on your list for Finance. The college is known for its PGDM degree in Finance and is located in the heart of the city, making it easily accessible for all.
IMI Delhi has one of the best faculty bodies in the country and offers a wide range of subjects to choose from. The course outlines are tailored to meet the industry requirements and are designed to provide theoretical knowledge as well as practical insights. You can expect to learn subjects like Wealth Management, Treasury Management, Merger & Acquisition, Private Equity, International Finance, Investment banking, and many more.
The classroom studies at IMI Delhi are completely case-based, which means you get an opportunity to relate theoretical learning with real-time challenges persisting in the industry. This approach prepares you well for the practical challenges you may face while working in the finance industry.
Apart from classroom studies, IMI Delhi also provides a plethora of opportunities in terms of live projects where a student can associate himself with an organization for a span ranging from 1 week to 1 month. This gives the students some degree of corporate exposure besides classroom case discussions.
To further enhance the learning experience, IMI Delhi has recently installed 8 new Bloomberg terminals in the college. This will increase and ease the accessibility of the same to the students, thereby providing them with a world-class learning experience.
So if you're looking to pursue a career in finance and want to get the best out of your management degree, IMI Delhi should definitely be on your radar.
Both colleges are private institutions and are considered amongst Tier-2 colleges for an MBA degree. We look at this exhaustive comparison through bullets and tables to compare the two.
|
Pointers |
BIMM |
XIME |
|
Total Fees (2 Yrs.) |
8.45 Lakhs |
10 Lakhs |
|
Rankings (Business Today) |
46 |
56 |
|
Companies Visiting |
Adani, Amazon, Deloitte, HCL, ICICI, Capital First etc. |
Accenture, KPMG, Deloitte, Muthoot, Godrej, etc. |
|
Overall Placement Rate |
95% |
94% |
|
Avg. Salary Offered |
6 LPA |
6.5-7 LPA |
|
Hostel Availability |
Yes |
Yes |
|
No. of Seats |
120 |
180 |
|
Closing Percentile |
N.A* |
CAT- 70%ile MAT- 85%ile CMAT- 80%ile |
*The college does not judge students on the basis of the score granted by any entrance exam. Hence, no cut off score.
Eligibility: A graduate from a UGC recognized university with 50% marks is eligible for admission to the course at both the places. Plus, the score of any exam from CAT/ MAT/ XAT/ CMAT is considered.
Admissions Process: A shortlist is prepared of candidates with a valid score in any exam amongst CAT/MAT/XAT/CMAT in both the colleges. The GD+Essay Writing followed by Personal Interview after the shortlist completes the process. BIMM also accepts the score of MAH CET and XIME considers ATMA and GMAT scores.
Course Curriculum: Following the pattern of London Business School with emphasis on producing industry ready candidates, BIMM appears appealing. At the same time, positive reviews regarding Academic engagement at XIME presents the curriculum in a bright light.
Other: The location of XIME being Bangalore, it claims being accessible to giants in the industry, thus ensuring better placements for students. As far as 'Student Life' is concerned, less focus on extracurricular activities, presents XIME in a bad light compared to BIMM.
To conclude, with a low RoI, XIME here seems to fall short in comparison to BIMM but covers up in academics and faculty.
Consulting firms were a popular choice among students, with over 38 percent of the batch being placed in this field. Additionally, more than 21 percent of the Finance Management batch landed roles with Investment Banking and Private Equity firms. The finance domain saw the participation of both domestic and international companies, offering roles in analytics, wealth management, and private banking. In fact, around 20 percent of the Finance batch received offers for Investment Banking and Private Equity roles, which is a record high for the cohort. Prominent recruiters like Avendus Capital, Axis Capital, GEF Capital, Goldman Sachs, and JM Financial rolled out multiple offers to candidates.
Another noteworthy aspect of the placements process was the participation of E-Commerce industry leaders like Amazon and Flipkart. About 12 percent of the batch received offers from these companies, with roles across domains such as Supply Chain and Operations Management, Finance Management, and Management Trainee being offered to students.
Overall, the placements process at SPJIMR in 2022 was impressive and offered students a wide range of opportunities in various domains. If you're considering SPJIMR for your business education, you can be assured of a strong placements process that provides ample opportunities to kickstart your career.
Both the institutes are excellent for finance specialization. NMIMS Bangalore is like a shadow to its main campus NMIMS Mumbai, similarly, IMT Hyderabad is a fraction of IMT Ghaziabad. You will receive decent teaching in both institutions.
The following table gives a brief insight into placement and fee structure:
| Criteria | IMT Hyderabad | NMIMS Bangalore |
| Tuition Fee | INR 12.03 Lakhs | INR 9.02 Lakhs |
| Average Placement | INR 7.64 LPA | INR 10.5 LPA |
| Highest Placement | INR 16.5 LPA | INR 18 LPA |
Overall, both the institutes are worth considering.
These are some of the roles that you can expect after graduation from Tapmi in the financial sector:
JBIMS (Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of Management Studies) and NITIE (National Institute of Industrial Engineering) are both highly regarded management colleges in India, with MBA programs in Finance and Operations, respectively. Personal preferences, professional aspirations, and industry requirements can all play a role in deciding between the two institutes.
|
Particulars |
JBIMS |
NITIE |
|
Average Package |
INR 23.16 LPA |
INR 25.27 LPA |
|
Highest Package |
INR 44 LPA |
INR 78.20 LPA |
|
Fees |
INR 305,000 per year |
INR 703,000 per year |
JBIMS is a Mumbai-based business school noted for its strong finance program. The institute's academic program is demanding, including topics such as financial markets, corporate finance, and investment banking. Top recruiters such as Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, and Citibank often hire from the school, demonstrating the institute's strong placement record in the finance industry.
NITIE, on the other hand, is a Mumbai-based university that provides a specialized MBA program in Operations Management. With courses including Supply Chain Management, Logistics, and Quality Management, the institute puts a significant emphasis on industrial engineering and operations research. Top recruiters such as Amazon, Flipkart, and Tata Motors, among others, have visited the school and have a constant high placement record in the operations area.
The following subjects are offered in IIMs, JBIMS, FMS and IIFT.