For the Human Resource Management program, the overall cut-off for male engineering applicants is 93 percentile, while it is 91 percentile for female engineering students.
Male applicants with non-engineering backgrounds must have a 90 percentile, while female applicants with non-engineering backgrounds must have an 88 percentile. It's possible that even with a high percentile, you might not be chosen if you have a poor interview performance.
While it's helpful to have some sense of scale, I'd advise shooting for the stars and ignoring percentiles for the time being.
It is hard to compare one specific major or stream but whatever is in the public domain the general ranking of these three colleges in HR domain quality-wise and RoI-wise is given below in a table.
|
Quality wise |
RoI wise |
|
XLRI |
TISS |
|
TISS |
XLRI |
|
SCMHRD |
SCMHRD |
|
MDI |
MDI |
Below is a table comparing these colleges on absolute numbers like fees, highest package, and average package.
|
Institution |
Fees (approx.) |
Highest Package |
Average Salary |
Median Package |
|
XLRI |
INR 26 lakhs |
INR 1.1 CPA |
INR 32.7 LPA |
INR 30 LPA |
|
TISS |
INR 1.4 lakhs |
INR 49 LPA |
INR 27.22 LPA |
INR 25.75 LPA |
|
MDI |
INR 23.5 lakhs |
INR 60 LPA |
INR 26.1 LPA |
INR 26.13 LPA |
|
SCMHRD |
INR 22.1 lakhs |
INR 67.60 LPA (International) INR 35.02 LPA (Domestic) |
INR 23.71 LPA |
INR 22 LPA |
For HR domain XLRI is the best and RoI wise for HR domain TISS is the best.
MDI Gurgaon is one of the elite B Schools of India that offers post graduation programs such as
The table below shows the placement statistics of the MDI Gurgaon PGP-HR program
|
Particulars |
Statistics |
|
Number of offers |
58 |
|
Highest CTC |
INR 35.57 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters |
Aditya Birla Group, Google, JSW Group, Accenture Strategy, AON Consulting, Deloitte USI, Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories, Flipkart, Mahindra & Mahindra, PhonePe & PwC US Advisory |
XLRI is not only good for HRM but also good for General business management, finance, and marketing. The HRM program in this college is way better than any other college.
The college has got the best faculties for their programs. The curriculum has been developed in a way to give information and knowledge about the subject concerned and will help you in better learning. Many clubs and committees are formed which will help you in developing your communication and leadership skills.
The curriculum is developed in such a manner that you will be able to handle the stress of the workplace. The college has got a very strong alumni base. There is no reservation quota in the selection process.
The placement highlights of XLRI for the year 2020-21 are good. The highest salary offered was 50 LPA while the average salary was 25.08 LPA. The top recruiters were consulting, sales and marketing, and BFSI.
XLRI offers a two years Human Resource program at PGD level and Symbiosis Pune offers an MBA and a Diploma in HR Management. The XLRI program has been ranked the best in Asia Pacific. Both institutes receive employment offers from names like Citibank, Yes Bank, Axis Bank, Mercer, Ranbaxy, Dabur etc.
The table below shows the information on the institute and programs-
|
Parameters |
XLRI (HR) |
Symbiosis Pune (HR) |
|
Placement Percentage |
100 |
100 |
|
Campus size (acres) |
50 |
300 |
|
Total Seats |
120-180 |
182 |
|
Fee |
INR 4.10-23.0 LPA |
INR 2.3 - 6.15 LPA |
|
Average Package |
INR 23 LPA |
INR 27.18 LPA |
Admission Process
Infrastructure and Faculty
Both institutes have 5 - 10 faculty members with NET and PhD qualifications.
Placement Details
Students can make a choice based on facts listed above in coherence with future goals.
If you do not have a specific preference for specialty, the XLRI HRM course is the greatest fit for your needs.
The HRM course at XLRI Jamshedpur is the best in Asia. They receive incredible placements, and the profiles they get are better than any other HR programme in India. Few students in XL HR have been placed in Consulting and General Management roles, which are in high demand at major business schools. Almost all of the top HR in India's leading firms are from XL Jamshedpur, which helps with networking and job advancement. They have a fantastic alumni network. The recent appointment of Leena Nair as Chanel's global CEO is an illustration of how their graduates (XL HR) have performed.
For MBA in HR both RIIM, Pune, and Indira Institute of Management are good options. Both the institutes are AICTE approved.
Admission:
The entrance examinations accepted for MBA admission at both the institutes are CAT/XAT/MAT/CMAT/MHCET. For final selection, Group Discussion and Personal Interviews are conducted.
The course fee for MBA at RIIM and IIMP is 7.2 lakhs and 4.4 lakhs.
Placements: Both the institute offers similar placement opportunities for MBA HR. The salary package received by the students of this specialization ranges between 5-6 lakhs at both the institutes.
|
Institute |
Highest CTC |
Average CTC |
|
IIMP |
13.8 LPA |
5.2 LPA |
|
RIIM |
8.92 LPA |
4.5 LPA |
Major recruiters at RIIM are Oppo, Kohler, Paytm, etc. Whereas, the top recruiters at IIMP are ICICI Bank, Mother Dairy, Amazon, etc.
RIIM takes a lesser number of students for the MBA in HR as compared to the Indira Institute of Management so that every individual gets proper attention for intellectual and logical growth. The placement rate is also higher in RIIM compared to the Indira Institute of Management.
RIIM also has a special training program for its students. 500+ hours for Advance Employability and Leadership Development Program and two weeks residential management development program from IIM Indore with 6 certifications.
If you have decided to take up Human Resources as your specialization then your top priority should be options such as XLRI, TISS, SCMHRD, and MDI. Beyond these options the placement opportunities in other colleges for the HR domain are limited and you have to struggle to bag good offers. Even top IIM’s receive very limited opportunities for the domain of Human resources.
A total of 170 students were there in the 2020 batch at IIM Shillong. Out of the 185 offers made, only 7% of them were from Human Resources & operations domain combined.
The highest package received by the students in this domain was 48.5 LPA. Some of the companies that visited for the particular domains were D.E. Shaw, Moglix, TATA Steel, Tillomed Laboratories, and Titan. An increase in the package offered was recorded in this season by 42.5%.
It must be noted that very few students opt for HR as a career option in IIM Shillong. You will not find great opportunities in this domain.
Both the colleges are pretty good if you choose to enroll in them. According to the IIRF rankings for 2022, MDI was ranked 2nd in the top 10 private management schools, while SCMHRD secured 6th rank. MDI also has a bigger alumni network.
The placements for the year for MDI-HR were 26.42 LPA and the median package is 25 LPA. During the same time frame, SCMHRD recorded an average salary of 23.71L and a median salary of 22 LPA.
Placements alone don’t determine if one college is better than the other.
Not just this year, joining SCMHRD is a great decision in the near future for any stream and for HR it is even better.
Below is a table showing the fees, highest salary package (international and domestic), average salary package, and the median salary package as of 2023 figures;
|
College |
Fees (in INR) |
Highest Package (Domestic) |
Highest Package (International) |
Average Package |
Median Package |
|
SCMHRD |
22.1 Lakhs |
INR 35.02 LPA |
INR 67.60 LPA |
INR 23.71 LPA |
INR 22 LPA |
So, as you can see the RoI is good enough so you can go for the loan as well, but go for a loan from a government bank.