Choosing a B-school can be a tricky decision especially when it comes to ROI. I understand that ROI is one of the most important factors when it comes to MBA courses since funding your education with loans come with its own set of challenges. But the institutes that you have mentioned above certainly surpass the challenges since they belong to the tier 1 category.
You might come across articles and blogs stating that FMS or JBIMS do not provide a typical MBA environment but for me, that discussion does not even make sense. What is an MBA environment after all? You spent 2 years of your life at the campus and wish to land a good job. FMS, JBIMS, and IIT Bombay all three have good market reputations, they home the best candidates and charge minimal fees. So, if ROI is even a little bit of a concern for you, go for these colleges without any second thought or regret.
IIM Bangalore and IIM Kozhikode both are premier business schools in India. A good overall profile and high CAT percentile are mandatory to get into both IIMs. Both of them rank high in the B-school rankings and offer great placements and career opportunities to students. The rigorous life of students at top IIMs prepares students to be leaders of tomorrow.
The table below gives a comparison of both the colleges.
|
Criteria |
IIM Bangalore |
IIM Kozhikode |
|
Ranking |
#2 in NIRF 2021 |
#6 in NIRF 2021 |
|
Average CTC Offered (PGP) |
INR 26.18 LPA |
INR 23.08 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters |
Accenture, BCG, Amazon, Goldman Sachs, Microsoft, McKinsey & Company |
Amazon, Deloitte, EY, JP Morgan Chase, KPMG, PwC |
|
Notable Alumni |
Nandan Nilekani, Kiran Mazumdar Shaw, Mohandas Pai, Harsha Bhogle |
Aparna Popat, Rajeev Chandrasekhar, Anand Mahindra |
Both are good but IIM Bangalore is better than IIM Kozhikode in terms of ranking, placement, alumni network etc.
It is not a wise decision to waste another year preparing for IIM Allahabad or Bangalore because the profiles of students in the top 10 colleges in India are very similar. It is better to have a strong profile and work one's way up to the top management roles in the industry.
It is more important to focus on your profile and career growth rather than the college's brand value. It is not worth risking another year to secure admission to a particular college, especially when there is no guarantee of success.
You can get into a top 30 college and do decently, but I know of people from non-IIM colleges who are in top management roles in investment banking and top tech companies. Your success is not solely determined by the college's brand value.
You should not waste time and energy chasing a college's brand value and it is essential to focus on building a good profile and working towards one's career goals. An example is Indra Nooyi, who came from XLRI, which emphasizes that success is not determined by the college's brand value.
If you measure the worth of a degree by its salary, you will never be satisfied, and I recommend that you do not pursue an MBA. Money is only one of many factors to consider before beginning an MBA program. The salary you have is something that most people do not get even after an MBA/Executive MBA; average salary packages range between Rs. 22 and Rs. 25 lakhs. You are already earning twice as much.
If you want to advance your knowledge of business/strategy/finance/organizational behavior and advance to a higher position where you can have a significant impact, an MBA is unquestionably a good option. However, there is no guarantee that you will earn more than 50 lakhs after completing your EMBA. Go for it if you want to learn and are willing to take a pay cut after your MBA. Don't do it if you're only in it for the money. You could invest in the stock market and watch your money double over time. MBA does not magically transform 50 lakhs into 1 crore.
Don’t choose the institute based on the city. As you will barely get to go out of the campus because of the academic loads in both the colleges.
IIM Bangalore offers the best student exchange programs. This college has helped a lot of students in building their careers. Most of the alumni of IIM Bangalore are settled abroad. So, it is definitely a good option for your studies. Also, it will take over 10 years for Bangalore to be completely unlivable. So, you don’t need to worry about that for the duration of your course.
However, if you want a pollution-free campus then IIM Kozhikode will be a better choice for you. The hostel rooms of this college are very good along with food. You will find a lot of learning opportunities over there.
Choose according to your convenience and don’t take City as a major parameter for your decision.
When compared to the top IIMs, SPJIMR is a rather moderately good B School. Yet the placements and roles offered by the B School are at par with that of IIMs. The major USP of the B School is its profile-based evaluation. This means a certain candidate can make it into SPJIMR even if he was unable to get a high CAT or XAT score of 98-99 percentile provided that his profile is excellent. With the required skills, qualities, and a decent academic record you could get admission and meet not necessarily get a very high CAT score. This gives a wider spectrum for students to showcase their skills other than academics. There are some more key points where SPJIMR fares rather well when compared to IIMs or other B Schools.
Fees: The primary factor that distinguishes SPJIMR from the top B Schools is the moderate fees. SPJIMR PGDM fees for 2 years is ?20.42 Lakhs (Total Fees) while that of top IIMs is above 20 lakhs.
Placements: The entire placement drive is concluded quite fast and is at par with the top IIMs. SPJIMR Completes Final Placements 2023 with 46% Rise in Highest Salary at Rs. 77.8 LPA and 3% Rise in Average Salary at Rs. 33.02 LPA; Accenture, BCG, HUL, Godrej, ITC, KPMG, P&G being the major recruiters.
Batch size: This is an often underestimated aspect when in reality it affects both, placements and the quality of education. SPJIMR batch size is around 300 while that of most IIMs is 350-500. The low batch size results in better bonding between peers and close relations with the faculty.
Location: Located in the Finance capital of India, SPJIMR offers a plethora of advantages. Easy access to CXOs and practitioners gives the learning experience at SPJIMR a practical approach.
Curriculum: The curriculum is unique in the sense that it targets not just the student's IQ but also EQ and creates socially and emotionally aware managers. This unique course curriculum at SPJIMR offers three distinct levels of learning:
Pedagogy: Apart from the regular courses and teaching methodology employed at other premier B Schools, SPJIMR takes five key initiatives in the ‘Non-Classroom Learning’ area which include ADMAP, DOCC, Abhyudaya, PG Lab, and Science of Spirituality.
All these unique aspects make life at SPJIMR a very good experience compared to old IIMs.
There are many major reasons why ISB Hyderabad is not as popular as IIMs among Indian households. Some of them include
All these reasons are strong enough to persuade one against joining ISB Hyderabad and is thus not much popular among Indian households.
The reason why IIMs are popular in contrast to ISB Hyderabad are
So all this makes IIMs much popular in India despite ISB Hyderabad global rankings.
The first year is extremely challenging because you will be studying subjects that you have never studied before. Accounting would be required for an engineering graduate, and statistics would be required for a commerce graduate. This, along with other activities, constant submissions, and class tests, makes the first year academically demanding.
In the second year, students have the option of selecting their own subjects, so they can take courses that are less rigorous academically than others. There is an exchange term in the second year as well, and for students who choose to participate in an exchange program, this is the least academically demanding term of the entire program.