Having friends in both the institutes, I can say that overall, NIT Durgapur is a better choice among the two. But IIEST is also an excellent institute with national importance.
There are several factors that affect the placement in both the institutes, according to them here are some -
The following table shows important statistics for both institutes:
|
Categories |
IIEST |
NIT Durgapur |
|
Placement Percentage |
80% |
90-100% |
|
Highest CTC |
39 LPA |
33 LPA |
|
Average CTC |
10-15 LPA |
11 LPA |
|
Recruiting Companies |
TCS, Wipro, Wells Fargo, Deutsche Bank, etc. |
IBM, HCL, Infosys, ZS Associates, etc. |
NIT Durgapur is a more legit choice for students interested in placement than IIEST Shibpur.
The second-oldest engineering institute in the country is the Indian Institute of Engineering, Science & Technology, Shibpur (formerly named BESU and B. E. College). Since 2014, it has been listed as an Institute of National Significance like IITs or IISc by the Parliament's NITZER Act.
Courses Offered:
This Institute offers 5-year full-time dual degree courses (i.e. 10-semester courses) in the following divisions of the undergraduate course.
The Institute also offers a 5-year full-time undergraduate course in Architecture on a regular basis.
The Integrated Dual Degree Five-Year Curriculum or program for the following Departments of Science and Humanities are funded by the Arch Program, as stated above.
These departments have post-graduate and doctoral programs of their own. There are several specialized centers and schools offering PG and Ph.D. programs at this Institute.
One of my friends was in the same situation last year. He got IIEST Shibpur Metallurgy and Materials Engineering, Mining Engineering, and Civil Engineering along with a rank of 1383 in West Bengal State Merit List of NEET for MBBS admission converted with a mark of 462.
So, if you want to become a doctor and serve people and if it's the long-cherished dream of pursuing MBBS then you should leave IIEST and better prepare for NEET again. Different people will have different views regarding the decision of leaving a good college like IIEST but in the end, it completely depends upon your goals.
Here are some suggestions on these two options-
Biotech is a good branch with increasing scope. The Biotech Department of NIT Allahabad offers good facilities to its students. The college also organizes an annual Biotech fest by the name of “Biosangam”.
IT is a very safe option these days. It offers good career opportunities. To do well in this field, one has to stay updated on tech developments and work on one’s coding skills. This field requires self-training the most. I am not aware of the IT department at IIEST Shibpur. IT students at IIEST would know the best about the placement prospects.
Both these options are good. The choice depends on one’s interest area.
Indian Institute of Engineering Science and Technology Shibpur (IIEST Shibpur) is the second oldest engineering college in India. It offers 45 courses in Engineering, Management, Science, and Architecture. Admissions are conducted through central exams conducted by UGC like JEE, XAM, etc. IIEST has over 250 faculty members including regular guest faculty. It hosts 4000 students every year for their higher education. Even though the institute is engaged in a number of fields, it is most famous for its B.Tech and M.Tech course of Engineering.
Civil Engineering Department:
The Department of Civil Engineering is one of the oldest departments at IIEST Shibpur. The Civil Engineering course mainly deals with Structural engineering, geotechnical engineering, water resource engineering, environmental engineering, and transportation engineering.
Mining Engineering Department:
The Department of Mining Engineering at IIEST, Shibpur was the pioneer in imparting Mining Engineering education in the country. Today, it stands as one of the most diverse and vibrant departments encompassing all disciplines within Mining Engineering and associates areas.
Opportunities:
Courses and Duration:
Faculty:
The table given below gives a brief overview of both the institutes:
|
Course |
Admission Cut off |
Fees |
Placements |
Degrees Offered |
|
Civil Engineering |
19147 - 27598 |
1,36,000 |
57.14% |
B.Tech, M.Tech, P.hD |
|
Mining Engineering |
22516 - 31923 |
1,36,000 |
81.48% |
A dual degree, M.Tech, P.hD |
Thus it depends entirely upon the student and their interest in Civil or Mechanical Engineering that will help them choose a course. While it is important to mark these differences, any course or college can be the best for the student if he/she knows how to utilize the opportunity completely.
If you are trying for CSE branch then you should expect a CGPA between 9.10-9.3. But this CGPA may vary as well. You should have a word had in the 1st semester so that there is no problem while changing to any branch. You should also analyze the competition level in the college as well so that you can predict the CGPA for this.
At IIEST Shibpur there are fixed number of seats which needs to be filled by the students of other branches like in the case of CS and IT they allow up to 4 students while in the case of ETC they take up to 2 students. The eligibility for changing the branch is done by your CGPA and applications are usually accepted after the third week of July i.e. right after the starting of third semester.
Lot of applications are there and it depends upon your CGPA which branch you will be allocated. If you have a good CGPA then you will have more chances for getting your preferred branch.
If you consider the institutional ranks, then IIEST is always ahead of most of the NITs in India. Besides, the core branch and its placement statistics are also better in IIEST.
But in the case of IT and CSE, NIT Durgapur grasps a better position than IIEST. However, IIEST is not so behind, and there is a chance that IIEST will surpass its positions in the next 3 years for the subjects CSE and IT. It can be mentioned that the faculties of IIEST are also better than all of the NITs.
|
Categories |
NIT DGP |
IIEST Shibpur |
|
Course Fee |
5.56 lakh |
1.55 -1.94 lakh |
|
Placement Percentage |
68% |
90% |
|
Highest CTC |
23 LPA |
30 LPA |
|
Average CTC |
5-6 LPA |
12-15 LPA |
|
Recruiting Companies |
Amazon, Wipro, TCS, IOCL, etc. |
Tata Steel, Tata Power, Schneider Electric, PwC, ZS Associates, Microsoft, Infosys, etc. |
If you are planning for higher studies, then IIEST Shibpur would be a better choice. You will be associated with great professors as well as students from not only India but abroad as well.
However, if you are not getting your desired subject in IIEST, you could go for NIT DGP.
The mess menu at IIEST Shibpur is not fixed.This is how things work, at least for the first year hostels (Hostel 8,9,10) -
The IIEST mess food is decent, but in no way comparable to homemade food.
This is a frequently asked question among students navigating higher education decisions.
Important considerations:
For the most accurate information, contact the college admission office directly or consult the official prospectus and website.
On papers, there is. Each floor has a Wi-Fi router or sometimes 2 Wi-Fi routers installed for the students and also there is 1 JAXB Wi-Fi installed at a common point amidst all the hostels for common access.
But in reality, you would consider yourself lucky if you are in rooms like 01, 03 or 10, 11. These are the extreme most rooms on each floor and get good Wi-Fi connections with decent speed. If you get a room near to the router you might get a speed around 5mbps or sometimes even 10mbps with an average speed of 2mbps. But if you are not, then you have to depend on luck. Only when others are not using, you might get some decent speed around 1mbps.
Moreover, the college Wi-Fi blocks many sites. For example, you can’t open YouTube, till the afternoon. The library and departmental Wi-Fi are far better than the hostel ones. Sometimes, the CS and Chemistry dept. WiFi download speed reaches 100mbps.