All three colleges fall under the Tier 2 category of MBA colleges in India. However, TAPMI and GIM possess a slight edge over Nirma as they have a stronger brand reputation and placement figures. 

When it comes to TAPMI and GIM, the former is known for finance and marketing while the latter is known for marketing as some top FMCG companies recruit from there. GIM could be considered slightly better if someone wishes to pursue marketing, and it also has a smaller batch size than TAPMI. The bigger the batch size, the harder it is for the placement team of any college.

IMT is a well-established college and comparing it to a mediocre college like TAPMI is not justifiable. Of the two, IMT Ghaziabad is clearly a better choice. To explain further I have compared both these institutes on the basis of some parameters like

• Establishment: Both these institutes were established in 1980 so they carry an equal legacy.
• Alumni: Despite a similar legacy, IMT Ghaziabad alumni are placed in higher positions and top firms today. The extensive alumni network has opened gates for corporate and industry exposure. IMT Ghaziabad’s alumni comprise more than 300 CXOs.
• Location: IMT Ghaziabad enjoys a better location advantage over TAPMI
• Pedagogy: Both the Institutes are AACSB accredited and follow similar curriculums yet there is a stark difference in the quality of education. This is because of the better pedagogy at IMT Ghaziabad than at TAPMI.
• Faculty: IMT Ghaziabad's teaching methodology is way ahead of that of TAPMI and the credit goes to its excellent faculty with amazing profiles. They have great industry exposure and help the students grasp the concepts practically.
• Placements: IMT Ghaziabad has an upper hand in this aspect also. This can be explained further through the table below

From the table you can easily infer that the placement scenario is far better at IMT Ghaziabad than TAPMI. In fact in almost all aspects IMT Ghaziabad is way ahead so it’s definitely a better choice than TAPMI.

Let’s consider the following factors to draw a comparison between TAPMI, BIM Trichy, and KJ Somaiya.

Infrastructure: TAPMI has the most beautiful campus among three having a bigger library, Computer center, FINLAB from Bloomberg. You also get to share facilities from MIT and KMC like

• Swimming pool
• Cricket Ground
• Football ground
• Indoor Stadium 

BIM and KJ Somaiya also have a good campus but are not at par with the campus of TAPMI.

Recognition: TAMPI enjoys better recognition of the two owing to its AACSB accreditation.

Fees

• TAPMI: INR 8,00,000 per year
• KJ Somaiya: INR 9.59 Lakhs first year
• BIM Trichy: INR 7,75,200 per year

Placements: 

Based on fees, placements and infrastructure TAPMI is the best among the three colleges.

It is indeed true that TAPMI has a good reputation in the market, and it is well known for providing quality education and attracting high-quality students. Marketing exposure and placement for Marketing students are considered to be particularly strong at TAPMI, making it a popular choice for students interested in this field.

IMT Nagpur, on the other hand, also has its own strengths and maybe a better fit for some students. As you mentioned, the number of students per batch is a concern for both TAPMI and IMT Nagpur, and this could potentially impact the quality of education and the individual attention that students receive from faculty. Before making a final decision, it is indeed a good idea to visit the college websites and read the placement reports provided by NIRF to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the colleges' strengths and weaknesses.

In terms of the strict rules regarding attendance, it is important to be aware of these before making a final decision. Strict rules and regulations can be challenging for some students, so it is crucial to carefully consider your own study habits and how well you are likely to adapt to such an environment.

Ultimately, the best way to determine which college is right for you is to weigh your individual career goals, preferences, and priorities against the strengths and weaknesses of each college. By doing so, you can make an informed decision that will help you reach your full potential and achieve success in your chosen field.