Both the colleges, IIM A and MDI Gurgaon are premier b schools in India. IIM Ahmedabad holds the 1st rank among the IIMs and other top b schools. It has the best academic structure and exposure opportunities. Placements are exceptional and career opportunities are great.
The table gives a comparison between the two colleges.
Criteria |
IIM Ahmedabad |
MDI |
Ranking (2021) |
1st (NIRF) |
10th (NIRF) |
Student-Teacher Ratio |
3:1 |
9:1 |
Infrastructure |
State-of-the-art facilities, library, and hostel |
Modern facilities, library, and hostel |
Placements |
Excellent placement record with top companies |
Good placement record with top companies |
Average Salary (2021) |
INR 28.9 LPA |
INR 22.05 LPA |
Seeing the comparative analysis above, IIM Ahmedabad is better but the choice also depends on the individual goal as well.
MDI Gurgaon offers three postgraduate programs Post Graduate Programme in Management (PGPM) Post Graduate Programme in Human Resources (PGP-HR) Post Graduate Programme in International Management (PGP-IM) It accepts CAT and GMAT scores for admission to its postgraduate programs in management. Interested candidates must first fill out an online application form on the MDI Gurgaon website. The application form requires personal and academic details, along with work experience, if any. Eligibility for PGPM and PGP-HR You must have 50% marks or equivalent CGPA in both X and XII. You must have a Bachelor’s Degree of a minimum 3 years duration with at least 50% marks or equivalent CGPA in any discipline For PGPM-IM, a minimum of one year of work experience after graduation is mandatory. Candidates are shortlisted for Personal Interviews, Group Discussions, and Written Ability Tests (GD-PI- WAT) on the basis of CAT/GMAT score. After the GD-PI-WAT round, a merit list is prepared by assigning different weightage to the CAT score, GD-PI-WAT score and Application Score Components Weightage CAT Score 60% GD-PI-WAT (combined) 20% 10th, 12th marks, work experience, Gender Diversity, Academic Diversity 20% According to merit list, candidates are offered admission and also waitlist is prepared.
All three colleges are well-regarded in business. To choose between XLRI Jamshedpur (BM), MDI Gurgaon, and IIM Kozhikode, consider these things.
I would suggest you go for XLRI BM because it is the biggest name among the three choices that you have. Also, XLRI being the oldest B-school in the country and famed for its HR has alumni working in the HR department of all the major companies out there and you can leverage this alumni network to get greater prospects in the future.
All the companies in consulting and marketing profiles that visit IIM K or MDI also do visit XLRI and one won't miss out on anything but will only gain by being an XLRI Alumni. It is the oldest B-school and a worthy rival to IIM C which puts it in a league above IIM K or MDI.