According to the NIRF 2020 rankings, MNNIT Allahabad was ranked 48th, NIT Surathkal was ranked 13th, NIT Warangal was ranked 19thand MANIT Bhopal was ranked 65th in India 2020 for B.Tech courses (including ECE). Admission to each institute is done on the basis of rank secured in JEE Main.
Some necessary facts about the institutions regarding ECE course are tabulated below:
|
Particulars |
MNNIT Allahabad |
NIT Surathkal |
NIT Warangal |
MANIT Bhopal |
|
Eligibility criteria |
Passed10+2 in Science stream with minimum 75% marks |
Passed 10+2 in Science stream with a minimum 75% marks OR Have got top 20 percentile in 12th exam. |
Passed 10+2 with PCM acquiring minimum 75% marks |
Passed higher secondary exams acquiring 50% (minimum) in PCM and must have passed the AIEEE exam |
|
Fees (1st year) |
Rs 84,666 |
Rs 151,426 |
Rs 94,500 |
Rs 64,939 |
Placements:
Based on all the above facts and data, the preference order can be - NIT Warangal, NIT Surathkal, MANIT Bhopal, and then MNNIT Allahabad (if you want an advantage of home state quota). Otherwise, you can also prefer the preference order as NIT Warangal, NIT Surathkal, MNNIT Allahabad, and MANIT Bhopal.
It is not compulsory for students to opt for hostels at NIT Surathkal. A number of PGs and rented apartments are available for students around Surathkal as well as Mangaluru.
But there are various benefits of staying in the college hostel.
Infrastructure wise NIT Surathkal hostels are not that great. However, it is a whole other experience to stay in a college hostel and you should not miss out.
Here are some things you should consider while making a choice-
COEP does not stand at par with the other two colleges. You’ll have to choose between NITK and VNIT Nagpur. You must choose between the two based on the branch of your interest.
If you are considering pursuing engineering and wondering which branch to choose, there are some important things you should keep in mind while making a decision. Here are some key points to consider:
If you are still interested in pursuing Civil engineering despite the challenges, then you may want to consider NIT Warangal. According to the author of the original statement, this institution is better than NIT Surathkal. However, keep in mind that this is a subjective opinion and you should do your own research before making a decision.
To make an informed decision, it's crucial to understand that changing your choice based on the college you get into won't have much impact. You should acknowledge that Electronics and Instrumentation in BITS Pilani Goa Campus and Electrical and Electronics in NIT Surathkal are two distinct engineering streams with different colleges, and both colleges are excellent in their own right.
Your selection of the branch should entirely depend on your interest. If you are intrigued by electrical or electronic circuits or have been fascinated by electricity since childhood, EEE is the perfect fit for you. Conversely, if you have an interest in instruments or daily life gadgets that make our lives more comfortable, you should opt for E&I.
Keep in mind that EEE focuses on circuit design and development, while E&I focuses on circuit implementation in industries or the real world. EEE is a core branch that concentrates on its domain, but E&I combines all other core branches such as Mechanical, Electronics, Electrical, and even Computer Science.
Both EEE and E&I offer excellent job prospects in the market. E&I graduates can work in core fields or software industries. There is a plethora of industries related to electrical and electronics, so EEE also offers ample job opportunities. Therefore, both branches are exceptional in their way. Choose the one that piques your interest and don't sacrifice your area of interest due to college selection.
Since both the colleges are considered highly reputable and among the best in the country, you should focus on the branch. The choice of the branch directly depends on your inclinations and future goals.
To make it easier for you I have explained each branch in short:
Electrical and Instrumentation:
Electrical and Electronics:
Although the choice depends on your own interests, EE has a better scope than EIE.
One of my friends was doubtful whether the hindi-speaking culture of MNNIT will have any impact on her English communication skills. If you are doubtful regarding the same, I would say you need not worry uselessly.
Students from MNNIT clear CAT with good scores. This wouldn’t have been possible without clearing the CAT verbal paper. Students converse in Hindi on campus simply because most of them belong to North India. This won’t have any negative effect on your English proficiency. Also, the professors deliver lectures in English. Other than that, to keep enhancing your English skills, you can join the English Literature group of MNNIT.
As far as your options are concerned, MNNIT is known for its top notch education in CSE. It is one of the best colleges in India for a CSE program. Also, the placements offered at MNNIT are quite impressive, especially for its CSE branch.
According to me, you should choose CSE at MNNIT over IT at NIT Surathkal.
Honestly, there isn't any major difference between CSE and IT branches as both are related to computers. The job opportunities are almost similar. So, you should prioritize college over branch in your case. NIT Surathkal is much better than MNNIT Allahabad and this can be further understood through the points below
Location: NIT Surathkal has an advantage over NIT Allahabad due to its location near Bangalore, the IT hub of India. Most Bangalore-based companies firstly visit NITK Surathkal. Last year major companies like Microsoft, DE Shaw, Uber, Amazon, Oracle and visited the campus last year.
Coding Culture: Recently 23 students from NIT Surathkal were selected for Google Summer of Code (GSOC) which is 4th Highest in the World. It has secured 13th Rank in the ICPC Asia Contest which is the highest ranked of all NITs. NIT Surathkal is the only single NIT that became a finalist in the ACM ICPC World Contest.
Academics: Every year students win International awards proving that their academics are better than MNNIT Allahabad.
Campus Life: The campus life of NITK Surathkal is also better than NIT Allahabad as NITK Surathkal has a private beach with a lush green campus of 300 acres and its fest Incident is the largest Cultural event in South India
Placements: Refer to the table below for comparison of placement statistics
|
Particulars |
NIT Surathkal |
MNNIT Allahabad |
|
Total No. of Eligible Students |
1608 |
1391 |
|
No. of Students placed |
1385 |
1100 |
|
Highest CTC |
INR 45 LPA |
INR 1.18 CPA |
|
Average CTC |
INR 13.12 LPA |
INR 11.22 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters |
Microsoft, DE Shaw, Uber, Amazon, Oracle. |
Adobe, Country Delight, D.E. Shaw, Cognizant, Ericsson, Maruti Suzuki, etc |
In all, NIT Surathkal seems to be a much better option than MNNIT Allahabad after considering various factors.
Comparing NIT Surathkal with IITs is very vague because there are the old IITs as well as the new ones. So you will have to categorize them into 3 parts
Hope this helps you!
NIT Surathkal and NIT Warangal are leading institutes in India. Both of them have a good placement record in the Department of Chemical Engineering.
NIT Warangal has a branch change policy that helps you change your branch after the first semester (with a good CGPA). Most students prefer the CSE branch because they get ample opportunities in a particular field.
The final decision is yours. I hope you will make a wise decision