It’s difficult to determine which institute is better because the courses in the question are different. However, if a choice has to be made between the two colleges, one can look at the different criteria.
NIT Allahabad (Information Technology):
The college was ranked at 48 out of the 300 engineering colleges in India. The duration of the course Information Technology is 4 years. The course structure in NIT Allahabad is more or less the same as compared to other NITs.
Admission:
Placements:
NIT Surathkal (Mechanical Engineering):
The college was Ranked 21st by NIRF in Engineering colleges 2019.
Admission:
Placements:
The college is known for its placements, in the year 2019, the college provided 100% placement.
Therefore, if a college has to be chosen between two, one can look at the above parameters.
Mechanical is an option at NIT Jalandhar.
Although MNNIT Allahabad has a better brand name than NIT Jalandhar, the production branch has many disadvantages when compared to the mechanical branch.
Unless someone specifically mentions Production Engineering, you will have to compete with mechanical students at NIT Allahabad during placements and off-campus interviews. When compared to Mechanical, there are fewer job opportunities.
There may now be one or two PSUs with separate vacancies for Production students. Mechanical paper is required in order to obtain PSUs, which are extremely difficult to crack. GATE is very important for core branches, and Mechanical has a high level of competition compared to other branches. Only if you intend to change your branch after one year should you enroll in NIT Allahabad; otherwise, do not.
BITS Goa CSE is a better option than NIT Allahabad. It has an excellent infrastructure and offers better placement opportunities. Recent highlights of BITS Goa placement show the average package to be around INR 15-16 LPA. Microsoft, Apple, Google, Amazon, Flipkart, Adobe, etc. recruit from the campus.
Here are the 2023 closing ranks for round 6 of JoSAA counseling to get into B.Tech Mechanical at MNNIT Allahabad through State Quota (Gender-neutral seats)-
|
Seat Type |
Closing Rank |
|
Open |
20112 |
|
SC |
3313 |
|
ST |
2642 |
|
EwS |
3522 |
|
OBC-NCL |
7622 |
Consult some seniors from MNNIT to figure out the marks corresponding to these ranks.
The competition to get into MNNIT Allahabad is fairly high, so prepare well for your JEE Mains.
These are the 2023 closing ranks for round 6 of JoSAA counseling to get into B.Tech CSE at MNNIT Allahabad (for SC category students, not including the SC-PwD category) -
|
Quota |
Gender |
Closing Rank |
|
Home State |
Gender-Neutral |
968 |
|
Home State |
Female-only (including Supernumerary) |
1751 |
|
Other State |
Gender-Neutral |
965 |
|
Other State |
Female-only (including Supernumerary) |
2371 |
Reach out to some seniors from MNNIT to find the approximate marks corresponding to these ranks.
MNNIT Allahabad is one of the best NITs of North India, and the competition to get in is quite high. Prepare well for your JEE Mains, and you’ll surely get through.
Both the IIIT Allahabad as well as MNNIT Allahabad are excellent institutes in their own way and there may not be a clear winner among the two. Here’s a comparison of the two institutes based on a few important parameters which can be of help.
Legacy:
Infrastructure:
Placements:
Coding Culture:
Mess:
At MNNIT Allahabad the seniors are quite helpful. They conduct coding classes or doubt clearing classes for juniors during the weekend.
In the end, both the colleges will give you many things, some good and some not so good. But the most important thing is how you utilize them properly.
MNNIT Allahabad has recently placed more than 2000 students in top companies like HP, HCL, Adobe and Oracle. Out of 167 students 163 were placed from the CSE department.
MNIT Jaipur is approved by AICTE and MHRD. It is funded by the Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD).
PEC Chandigarh is one of the pioneer engineering institutes in Punjab ranking 68th among the top engineering colleges as per NIRF ranking 2020.
Admission process:-
MNNIT Allahabad
MNIT Jaipur
PEC Chandigarh
Placements:
Tabulated below are the placement statistics for the institutes:
|
Categories |
MNNIT Allahabad |
MNIT Jaipur |
PEC Chandigarh |
|
Placement rate |
97.60% |
100% |
100% |
|
Highest CTC |
36 LPA |
37 LPA |
42 LPA |
|
Average CTC |
7.82 LPA |
8.9-13.36 LPA |
14 LPA |
The top recruiters are Accenture, Dell, Deloitte, Capgemini, Adobe, Infosys, IBM, TCS, etc.
Facilities
PEC Chandigarh is the most ideal institute for pursuing CSE course in terms of placements and facilities.
I have a few friends from MNNIT Allahabad and here is what they had to say.
Hope this helps.
MNNIT Allahabad is ranked 48th among top engineering institutes in India by MHRD’s 2020 NIRF rankings. The 2 years of M.Tech specializations offered by MNNIT in Mechanical Engineering (ME) include Computer-Aided Design & Manufacturing, Design, Production Engineering, Product Design & Development, and Part-Time Production Engineering.
NIT Bhopal is ranked 65th among top engineering institutes in India by MHRD’s 2020 NIRF rankings. It offers 4 years B.Tech in ECE with a total of 139 seats currently. The 2 years M.Tech in ECE offers specializations in two fields viz., Digital communication and VLSI & embedded systems. The entire faculty of the ECE department holds a doctorate in their respective fields.
Admission Process and Cut-off:
The cut off for JEE Main 2019 (round 7) of is as follows:
| Institutes | Opening Rank | Closing Rank |
| MNNIT Allahabad (ME) | 6602 | 13393 |
| NIT Durgapur (ECE) | 8723 | 13274 |
Placement:
The mechanical branch usually gets lesser core companies as compared to ECE and have to appear for non-core placement companies.
The choice of opting for either ME at MNNIT Allahabad or ECE at NIT Bhopal entirely lies with the students wanting to pursue it. Both of them are entirely different courses offered by nationally ranked institutes, hence should be opted by considering the stated facts and statistics.
MNNIT Allahabad is famous for its CSE and IT department because it is the first Indian institute to start with these departments.
In MNIT Allahabad, you can definitely slide your branch from Chemical to IT. The points to be considered to change your branch.
|
Placement |
Chemical Branch |
IT Branch |
CSE Branch |
|
No. of eligible students |
32 |
93 |
168 |
|
No. of students placed |
26 |
91 |
162 |
|
Average Package |
INR 8.82 LPA |
INR 17.22 LPA |
INR 18.02 LPA |
|
Highest Package |
INR 17.30 LPA |
INR 49 LPA |
INR 39 LPA |
|
Placement Percentage |
81.25% |
97.84% |
96.42% |
MNIT has an excellent coding culture. You will get an environment to study and watch yourself progressing passionately. There is a computer club, which is the tradition of MNIT. In the club, seniors impart knowledge to their interested juniors.
It is tough to change branches because the seats are fewer, and the competition for it is like cracking another JEE exam. All the branches of MNIT are decent but are worth sliding to CSE/IT. It will reap mouth-watering fruits in the future.